Dove Lifts Header
Elevator Modernisation in Nigeria – Upgrade or Replace Your Old Lift?

Elevator Modernisation in Nigeria – Upgrade or Replace Your Old Lift?

If your elevator is over 15 years old, breaks down often, or fails SON inspection, you must decide: modernise the key components or replace the entire system. Modernisation costs 40–60% of a new lift and takes half the time. Replacement gives you a full warranty. The right choice depends on the condition of your hoistway and your budget.

[Image: A Dove Lifts engineer inspecting an old relay-controlled elevator panel beside a new MRL controller in a Lagos office building.]

Signs Your Elevator Needs Modernisation

You need modernisation if the car and doors are sound but the controller, motor, or safety devices are obsolete. Look for relay-based control panels, frequent floor-leveling faults, and slow door cycles. These are symptoms of outdated technology, not a worn structure.

The most common sign is an obsolete controller. A hard fact: Relay logic panels use mechanical contacts that wear out after roughly 500,000 operations. A busy Lagos office lift reaches that figure in three years. After that, the lift stops between floors, mislevels, or refuses to answer calls. Spare relays become hard to source. Technicians spend hours tracing faults. We have replaced relay panels in Ikoyi buildings where the controller dated back to the 1990s. The car and doors were still serviceable.

Another sign is poor levelling. A hard fact: EN 81‑20 requires the car floor to align with the landing within ±10 mm. Older AC two‑speed drives drift beyond this tolerance as components age. Passengers trip on the step. Wheelchairs and trolleys catch on the sill. This is a safety issue, not just an annoyance. A modern variable‑voltage variable‑frequency (VVVF) drive corrects levelling automatically.

Slow doors are the third sign. A hard fact: EN 81‑20 requires landing doors to close within a defined kinetic energy limit to prevent injury. Old doors with DC motors and mechanical cams cannot meet this. They close slowly to stay safe, which reduces handling capacity. New doors with VVVF operators close faster and safer. In a Victoria Island office block, modernising the doors alone cut the round‑trip time by 12 seconds.

Constant breakdowns complete the picture. If your lift fails more than six times a year, the cost of emergency repairs approaches the cost of modernisation. One Abuja commercial building spent ₦2.8 million on call‑outs in a single year. The modernisation of the same lift cost ₦9 million and eliminated the breakdowns. Once you recognise these signs, you must check whether the structure can support modernisation.

When Replacement Is the Better Choice

You should replace the entire elevator if the hoistway, pit, or machine room is structurally deficient. Rusted guide rails, a cracked pit floor, or a leaking shaft wall cannot be fixed by modernisation alone. A worn gearbox or sheave also pushes the decision toward full replacement.

Structural problems are the clearest signal. A hard fact: EN 81‑20 requires guide rails to be straight within 1 mm over 5 metres. Rails that have shifted because of building settlement cannot be realigned cheaply. A Lagos Island building we surveyed had rails out of tolerance by 18 mm. The car shook violently at every stop. Replacing the rails meant cutting open the shaft walls. At that point, a full replacement with new rails and a new car was more economical.

A failing gearbox is another trigger. A hard fact: Geared traction machines typically need a gearbox overhaul or replacement after 15 to 20 years. The overhaul costs 30–40% of a new gearless machine. A new machine brings higher efficiency and lower energy bills. In most cases, we recommend replacing the machine and controller together rather than overhauling the old gearbox. The energy savings from a gearless permanent magnet motor recover the extra cost within four years.

Capacity problems also justify replacement. If your building has grown and the lift is now undersized, modernisation cannot add capacity. A hard fact: EN 81‑20 ties the rated load to the car area. You cannot simply raise the load limit without enlarging the car. A Surulere residential block added two floors but kept its original 630 kg lift. Residents wait in long queues every morning. Only a larger replacement lift solves that.

Finally, spare parts availability drives the decision. If the manufacturer no longer supports your model, every repair becomes a fabrication job. A hard fact: SON NIS 326:2017 requires lifts to be maintained with parts that meet the original safety specification. Fabricated parts rarely meet it. When parts dry up, replacement is the only compliant path. Once you know replacement is needed, the cost comparison becomes the deciding factor.

Cost Comparison – Modernisation vs Replacement

Modernisation costs 40–60% of a new elevator. For a five‑stop passenger lift in Lagos, modernisation runs ₦8–₦14 million. A full replacement costs ₦20–₦35 million. The gap is real, but modernisation carries hidden costs you must budget for.

The modernisation figure covers the controller, machine, door operators, car interior, and safety devices. A hard fact: EN 81‑20 requires modernised lifts to meet current safety standards for the upgraded components, including the overspeed governor and door interlocks. That means the old governor and locks usually must be replaced too. Labour and commissioning add 20–25% on top of parts. Downtime is four to six weeks.

The replacement figure includes a new car, new rails, new doors, a new controller, and a new machine. A hard fact: A new lift comes with a factory test certificate and a fresh EN 81‑20 certification under SON CAP. That documentation supports your LASG permit and insurance. Replacement downtime is six to eight weeks because the old lift must be dismantled first. We usually keep one lift running in multi‑lift buildings to reduce disruption.

The hidden cost of modernisation is the hoistway condition. If the rails need realignment or the pit needs waterproofing, modernisation costs climb quickly. A hard fact: Pit waterproofing in coastal Lagos, where the water table is high, can add ₦1.5–₦3 million. If you skip it, the new controller sits above a damp pit and fails within two years. We always include a pit and shaft survey in our modernisation quote.

Energy is the long‑term differentiator. A hard fact: ISO 25745‑2 rates a new gearless MRL as Class A or B. A modernised old geared machine with a new VVVF drive reaches Class C at best. Over ten years, the replacement saves roughly ₦2–₦4 million more in electricity than the modernisation option. In Abuja commercial hubs with high Band A tariffs, the gap widens. Once you have both numbers, you can plan the project timeline and permits

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *